Negotiation is the conversation partners have before a scene to agree on what will and will not happen. It is where consent becomes specific. A yes/no/maybe list is one of the simplest tools for making that conversation easier, especially when you are new or playing with someone for the first time.
What a yes/no/maybe list is
It is a list of activities that each partner marks privately:
- Yes: things you want to try or already enjoy.
- Maybe: things you are curious about, or would only try in certain conditions.
- No: things you do not want to do. These are your limits.
You then compare lists together. The overlap of two “yes” answers is a good place to start. “Maybe” items are for discussion, never for surprises.
Hard limits and soft limits
A hard limit is a firm no that is not up for discussion. A soft limit is something you are hesitant about, or would only consider in specific circumstances. Both deserve respect. Pushing on someone’s limits outside of what was agreed is a consent violation.
What to cover in negotiation
- Each partner’s yes, maybe and no items
- Safewords or signals, including a non-verbal one
- Any health considerations, injuries or triggers to avoid
- Where the scene will happen and how long it will last
- Protection and safer-sex practices, if relevant
- Aftercare preferences (see our aftercare guide)
- How and when you will check in afterwards
Tips for a good negotiation
- Negotiate when you are clear-headed. Not in the middle of a scene and not after drinking.
- Be specific. “Light” means different things to different people. Describe what you mean.
- It is okay to change your mind. A yes today can become a no later, and consent can be withdrawn at any time.
- Start smaller with new partners. Build trust over several meetings before exploring “maybe” items.
For the principles behind this, read our guide to consent, safewords, SSC and RACK. If you have taken an online BDSM test, your results can help you fill in your list. Our article on BDSM test results explains how.
Negotiation when dating online
It is fine to share broad interests and limits in messages, but keep detailed negotiation for when you have met and built some trust. Meet in public first, ideally at a munch, and follow our kink dating safety tips.
A simple negotiation checklist
- Who and where: who is involved, where you will play and who knows you are there.
- What: activities from both partners’ yes lists, and anything from the maybe list you agree to try.
- Limits: hard limits (never) and soft limits (only with care or discussion).
- Signals: safeword, slow-down word and a non-verbal signal.
- Health: injuries, conditions, medications or triggers the other person should know about.
- Aftercare: what each person needs afterwards and how you will check in the next day.
Revisit your list regularly
Limits and interests change. Update your yes/no/maybe list every few months or after a significant experience, and share changes with regular partners before your next scene. Treat negotiation as an ongoing conversation rather than a one-time contract. Read more about consent and safewords.
Frequently asked questions
Do experienced players still negotiate?
Yes. Long-term partners negotiate more briefly, but they still check in before trying anything new.
What if we disagree on a maybe?
Leave it out. Anything that is not a clear yes from both people stays off the table.
Ready to meet partners who communicate? Join FetDig free. No credit card, no upsells, 18+ only.
Frequently asked questions
What is a yes/no/maybe list?
A checklist of activities each partner marks as yes, no or maybe, used to guide negotiation before a scene.
What is the difference between hard and soft limits?
Hard limits are never okay. Soft limits might be explored carefully, with discussion and consent.
Should negotiation happen every time?
Yes, at least briefly. Check in before each scene, as feelings and limits can change.


